Good Idea, Bad Idea

I have written previously about cover songs, and how awesome they could be.

There is, however, I higher likelihood of a cover song actually turning out worse than the original. This tends to happen more often than not, and is prominently featured at any given local fair.

So, as a continuation from the aforementioned post, I thought I would share with you some lovely (or, perhaps, not so lovely) contrasts of covers.

Good Cover: Disturbed’s version of U2’s “I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For,” entitled “ISHFWILF”

While I’m not much of a Disturbed fan, I will admit that lead singer David Draiman and company do put out some pretty decent covers, including Tears for Fears’ “Shout” and Genesis’ classic “Land of Confusion.”

Bad Cover: Another effort to reprise a U2 classic, this time from Punk band Jawbreaker. Here is their excruciatingly painful version of “With or Without You,” entitled “With or Without U2.”

This cover is terrible, and I actually like Jawbreaker otherwise. Not only is it a sophomoric bastardization of a classic U2 song, it’s also a terrible conglomerate of other classic songs haphazardly puked together in an obnoxious effort (or lack thereof) of a punk track.

  Good Cover: Iconic super group A Perfect Circle did a musically full cover of Led Zeppelin’s “When the Levee Breaks.”

The vocals are a bit odd at first, but anyone familiar with A Perfect Circle, TOOL, or just Maynard James Keenan in general should already expect that. They took out the bluesy feel of the song, and replaced it with a more mellow, ethereal sound common for most A Perfect Circle tunes.

Bad Cover: Alt Rock/Industrial Icon Trent Reznor, Indie queen Karen O, and award-winning sound engineer and English musician Atticus Ross all collaborated on a cover of Led Zeppelin’s “Immigrant Song,” and subsequently ruined it.

Between the weird imagery and the dated Industrial sound, I felt like this is a song and video that was played on repeat at a crappy Goth bar in the early 2000’s. I expected a lot more from this power trio, and my hopes were expertly dashed. Well done.

Good Cover: Breaking Benjamin participated on a Queen tribute album back in 2005 entitled “Killer Queen,” and they knocked it out of the park with their rendition of “Who Wants to Live Forever.”

It’s impossible to match the vocals of Freddie Mercury. The man was unbelievable. Frontman Benjamin Burnley knew this, so instead he and the band decided to focus more on the pure emotional power of the song. I’ve got to say, they pulled it off quite well.

THE WORST COVER IN THE HISTORY OF COVER SONGS: Early this year at the Glastonbury Music Festival, Kanye West single-handedly DESTROYED one of rock music’s most iconic songs, Queen’s “Bohemian Rhapsody.”

Not only did he just have the recording of intro playing, HE FORGOT THE LYRICS WHILE LIP-SYNCING TO THEM. Then, his pre-pubescent sounding vocals were so terrible, that he literally got booed off of the song a minute into it! As if all of this wasn’t bad enough, he had announced to the crowd at the festival that they were watching the “Greatest Living Rock Star.”


I’m not 100% sure just how many brain cells one must be lacking to make a statement like that, but clearly West’s well-documented megalomania has solidified the fact that this man is just downright delusional. Even Slipknot and Stonesour frontman Corey Taylor called him out on that blatant lie.

There are a plethora of great and terrible covers out there, and this was just the tip of the figurative iceberg.

I would love to hear your favorite (and least favorite!) covers! Be sure to comment below, follow us on Twitter @The MusicJunkie8, Instagram @ThatMusicJunkie_ , and give us a “like” on Facebook! That Music Junkie

One thought on “Good Idea, Bad Idea

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s